Palm Bay Asked to Pay $7.7 Million for the Old Majors Golf Course, $670,000 Above the City’s Own Appraisal

Published on

- Advertisement -

PALM BAY. City Council votes Thursday night on a contract to buy 134 acres of the former Majors Golf Course for $7.7 million, a figure that sits $670,000 above what the city’s own appraiser says the land is worth, on an offer that expires the following day.

- Advertisement -

The property is the overgrown ribbon of dead fairways running through the middle of Bayside Lakes. It has been closed since 2022.

The numbers

According to the legislative memorandum from City Manager Matthew Morton, the city commissioned an appraisal from Tuttle-Armfield-Wagner Appraisal & Research, Inc. That appraisal concluded a fee simple “as-is” market value of $7,030,000, effective May 22, 2026, for the 135.19-acre subject area.

- Advertisement -

The seller then conducted its own appraisal verification. That one came back at approximately $7,700,000.

The seller is offering to sell at $7,700,000.

- Advertisement -

The offer expires Friday

The Florida Vacant Land Contract attached to the agenda item carries a hard acceptance deadline. The offer is withdrawn if it is not signed and delivered to all parties on or before November 20, 2026, the day after the council meeting.

Other terms in the contract:

  • The sellers are listed as Joy, LLC and HDC Development, LLC. The buyer is the City of Palm Bay.
  • The property is identified as 3375 Bayside Lakes Blvd SE, Unit GOLFCS, covering part of Tract O-2 and part of Windbrook Drive across Sections 19, 20 and 29.
  • Purchase price of $7,700,000, with a $100,000 initial deposit due to escrow within 21 days of the effective date and a $7,600,000 balance at closing.
  • The escrow agent is Spira & Beadle P.A.
  • The city would pay cash, with no financing contingency.
  • Closing on or before May 14, 2027.

What the city says it would build there

Morton’s memo lists the public uses under consideration: regional stormwater retention, treatment, attenuation and drainage; deep injection well infrastructure; reclaimed water storage, dispersal or disposal; potential future fresh water supply wells; utility access and operational buffers; a regional park of roughly 40 acres; and a loop trail with passive recreation, open space and natural areas.

City officials have said the purchase would be funded through park impact fees, utility enterprise funds and stormwater fees rather than general fund tax dollars.

What has not been checked yet

The memo also lays out the due diligence the city has not completed. The list is not short.

It calls for environmental assessments addressing potential contamination from “historical fertilizer, pesticide, herbicide, chemical storage, fuel storage, maintenance activities, and other former golf course operations.”

It calls for a comprehensive evaluation of the existing stormwater systems, ponds, drainage structures, conveyances and utilities on the site, including their condition, ownership, remaining useful life and anticipated rehabilitation or replacement costs.

It calls for an engineering evaluation of drainage conditions, watershed boundaries, hydraulic connectivity, stormwater storage capacity and flood elevations, including the potential impact of adjacent development on the facilities the city wants to build.

It calls for a preliminary technical and regulatory assessment of the proposed deep injection wells, reclaimed water facilities and potential potable water supply wells, covering permitting feasibility, subsurface conditions and utility conflicts.

And it calls for a review of title, deed restrictions, conservation easements, utility easements, drainage rights, access rights and “any continuing rights of residents, associations, or adjacent property owners,” naming the Bayside Lakes HOAs and POA. The memo separately flags the need to understand any “Joint Maintenance” obligation for the easement area contemplated in the First Addendum “for possible city liabilities.”

Staff is not recommending approval or denial. The recommendation reads, in full: “Council to provide direction.”

How the course got here

The Majors opened in 1999 as an 18-hole, par-72 public course designed by Arnold Palmer and Ed Seay. It was the amenity the Bayside Lakes community was built around.

In 2018, the city looked at buying the course while it was still open and operating, at a price around $2 million. That purchase died on a 3-2 council vote.

In December 2019, Joy LLC bought the property at auction for roughly $2.1 million.

The course closed for good in June 2022. As the property deteriorated, the city adopted a nuisance ordinance in January 2023 to address its condition.

In March 2024, the owner brought forward Eden at Bayside Lakes, a plan for 703 homes, townhomes and apartments. It was later scaled back to roughly 460 units. An earlier rezoning request had already been denied, and residents collected more than 3,000 signatures against the newer plan.

Those applications are still pending. According to the city’s project page, the Future Land Use Map amendment (CP24-00008) and preliminary development plan (PD24-00001) were submitted in mid-2024 and remain in their third round of review. The final development plan (FD24-00002) is on hold pending council approval of the preliminary plan. Because the applications predate the updated Land Development Code adopted in September 2024, they are being reviewed under the prior code.

The July vote

On July 2, 2026, council voted 5-0 to authorize city staff and the city’s broker to negotiate a vacant land contract for about 135 acres. Council set a negotiating range of $8.5 million to $10 million, with a $100,000 earnest money deposit, a cash purchase, 120 days of due diligence followed by closing 45 days later, and a requirement that any final contract return to council for approval. Roughly 54 acres would remain with the current owner.

The contract now in front of council came in at $7.7 million, below the range council authorized in July and above the appraisal the city obtained in May.

Deputy Mayor Mike Jaffe told council in July that the purpose was “to stop it from ever going into the hands of a large-scale developer,” and warned that “it’s only a matter of time before that state infill development act affects our community.”

Mayor Rob Medina called the property “the treasure, the gem in the city of Palm Bay,” adding, “You’ll never see that again.”

Councilman Chandler Langevin said in July he was “willing to entertain the eminent domain word.” City Attorney Patricia Smith told council the owners “are open to making a deal now where there really hasn’t been an opening before.”

Thursday

The item appears as number six under Unfinished and Old Business on the November 19 regular meeting agenda, which was posted Monday afternoon. The meeting begins at 6 p.m. in council chambers at 120 Malabar Road SE.

The same agenda carries a vote on turning the city’s 911 dispatch operation over to the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office, a $5,783,096 bid award for the Fred Poppe Regional Park bridge and roadway, and a $2,256,502 bid award for a city building buildout.

The Space Coast Rocket will be at Thursday’s meeting.

- Advertisement -

Criminal Defense
Bankruptcy · Evictions

WICKS LAW P.A.

Call or text for
free consult

321-733-2700

Eric Wicks, Esq.

1250 West Eau Gallie Blvd. G
Melbourne, FL 32935

Abogado Wicks habla español

Attorney Eric Wicks, Wicks Law P.A., Melbourne Florida

Upcoming Events

More like this

Palm Bay Council to Vote Thursday on Handing 911 Dispatch to the Sheriff’s Office

City Manager Matthew Morton's memo puts three actions before council, sets a March or April 2027 cut-over, and projects roughly $11 million in savings against a four-year cost of $3.26 million.

Family Launches GoFundMe for Joshua Bennett, Palm Bay Father Killed in Historic Flood

The family of Joshua Bennett, 34, who died after his truck became trapped in Palm Bay flood waters, has launched a GoFundMe to support his wife and four children.

Palm Bay Seeks New Operator for Aquatic Center as Nov. 30 Closure Nears

Palm Bay has issued an RFQ seeking an outside operator for the Palm Bay Aquatic Center, which is set to close Nov. 30 after months of budget debate.