City forced to settle over Vice Mayor Alfrey’s police brutality case costing tax payers thousands


Current national events involving police brutality have resurfaced a case where current Melbourne Vice Mayor Paul Alfrey, along with 2 other officers, beat and repeatedly tased an innocent man.

The complaint states that then officer Alfrey approached 2 men, Mark Chergosky and James Miley, who were shrimping under the Melbourne Causeway engaging them in casual conversation. Alfrey eventually asked that they provide him with their ID, which they complied with.

It was then that Alfrey was joined by 2 other Melbourne Police officers while Alfrey ran their information.

MPD Communications informed Alfrey that one of the defendants (Miley) had an arrest warrant for failure to pay a traffic ticket and driving on a suspended license. Communications never stated Chergosky had any warrants.

Alfrey however, went on to tell Chergosky that he also had a warrant for his arrest even though that was never communicated to him from the department.

Chergosky informed the officers that he indeed did not have a warrant for his arrest, and Miley reiterated to the officers that it was him who was wanted.

The other 2 officers acted on the information provided by Alfrey and told Chergosky his was under arrest and to put his hands behind his back.

He informed the 2 officers that he had an injury that prevented him from being able to place his hands behind his back. They then proceeded to force his arms behind his back by wrenching his arms. He screamed in pain reiterating that he was not physically capable of putting his arms behind his back.

The officers wrestled him to the ground and began punching, kneeing, and kicking him to comply while he was face down on the ground.

Alfrey put Miley, who actually had the warrant in handcuffs without incident, and then jumped on top of Chergosky to join the other 2 officers.

Once on top of him, Alfrey began to tase Chergosky in his back repeatedly telling him to put his hands behind his back. He again screamed out in pain and informed them again he could not put his hands behind his back, all while continuing to be tased by Alfrey.

The officers finally stopped their assault and placed him in handcuffs in front of his body. He was arrested and charged with resisting arrest without violence. He was 47 years old at the time.

Mark filed suit against the City of Melbourne and the officers. The officers claimed their actions were legal and claimed qualified immunity from suit against them individually.

The city eventually settled the case out of court in favor of Chergosky with financial compensation.

This is one incident of a string of behavioral and performance issues that lead to the eventual resignation of Alfrey in order to avoid further discipline. He was under investigation at the time of his resignation, and resigned prior to the outcome.

Alfrey still maintains however, that he is officially retired from the force and did not resign.

Alfrey is currently running for the office of Mayor of Melbourne.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.